tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5455108671364992297.post6052699306429512709..comments2023-12-23T00:42:26.651-08:00Comments on The Golden Ani-Versary of Anime (1963-2013): Golden-Ani Updates: Future Posts and Hall of Fame VotesGeoffhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/02385629483209026981noreply@blogger.comBlogger3125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5455108671364992297.post-46187422109073704672022-03-04T04:14:36.951-08:002022-03-04T04:14:36.951-08:00Top 25 casinos in the UK that accept American play...Top 25 casinos in the UK that accept American players<br />Top <a href="https://www.jtmhub.com/%eb%b0%80%ec%96%91%ec%b5%9c%ea%b3%a0%ec%8b%9c%ec%84%a4%ec%b6%9c%ec%9e%a5%eb%a7%88%ec%82%ac%ec%a7%80.html" rel="nofollow">밀양 출장샵</a> 25 casinos in the <a href="https://drmcd.com/%ec%9a%b8%ec%82%b0%ea%b4%91%ec%97%ad%ec%97%90-%eb%8c%80%ed%95%9c-%ec%9a%b0%ec%88%98%ed%95%9c%ec%b6%9c%ec%9e%a5%ec%95%88%eb%a7%88%eb%a6%ac%eb%b7%b0.html" rel="nofollow">울산광역 출장안마</a> UK that accept American players. In <a href="https://www.jtmhub.com/%ea%b5%b0%ed%8f%ac%ec%97%90-%eb%8c%80%ed%95%9c-%ec%9a%b0%ec%88%98%ed%95%9c%ec%b6%9c%ec%9e%a5%ec%83%b5%eb%a6%ac%eb%b7%b0.html" rel="nofollow">군포 출장마사지</a> total, there are a ton of Canadian <a href="https://www.mapyro.com/%ec%9b%90%ec%a3%bc%ec%b6%9c%ec%9e%a5%ec%83%b5.html" rel="nofollow">원주 출장마사지</a> players living in the United States who <a href="https://www.jtmhub.com/%eb%8c%80%ec%a0%84%ea%b4%91%ec%97%ad%ec%b6%9c%ec%9e%a5%ec%83%b5%ec%9d%b8%ea%b8%b0-%ec%88%9c%ec%9c%84.html" rel="nofollow">대전광역 출장안마</a> arejadynehackenberghttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11041746761562200815noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5455108671364992297.post-51323257891027659102013-06-08T08:20:57.688-07:002013-06-08T08:20:57.688-07:00You know most of my thoughts already, influenced b...You know most of my thoughts already, influenced by AFI's 100 Years 100 Movies list. But I'll restate some of them for debating here.<br /><br />If the original goal of this HoF is to enumerate 50 anime over 50 years, eligibility should extend through all 50 years. But there are caveats.<br /><br />Guidelines! What are you looking for exactly? Outstanding critical quality? Longevity? Mass appeal and commercial success? Trend setter or innovator? Decide which qualities are most important and insist your voting body make selections based on them.<br /><br />Like Brian said, you, or better a committee, should provide a short but thorough list of nominees (200-250?).<br /><br />Each ballot should have a spot or two for write-in titles in case the nominee list missed something or for personal flavor.<br /><br />True HoF-style voting, with limited total votes and 60% cutoff and such, is appropriate for an annual voting system where new candidates and past nominees return for eligibility each year. If this is going to be a one time thing, we want to get everything in one go. If that is indeed the case, voters should expand their lists to as many titles as there are spots (50).<br /><br />I'm also in favor of a closed voting pool, perhaps extending it to contributors + 2 friends each (each writer who wants to participate nominates 2 colleagues). There are a lot of well-connected writers attached to this project; who knows who else we can rope into it if a friend asks them to join.<br /><br />I like the idea of automatic inclusions, though what qualifies is open to debate.<br /><br />I'm against lumping franchises together. A title should stand on its own, and if sequels deserve recognition too, so be it. If Godfather I, II, and III are distinctly acclaimed (or derided) entities so too should anime titles. You also get into hairy situations with remakes, spinoffs, and quasi-sequels. Are both Fullmetal Alchemist or Hunter x Hunter series in equal standing? Would Diebuster be attached to Gunbuster despite 15 years apart and a world of difference in production philosophy? Keep them all separate.<br /><br />Give voters enough time to research the nominees. Whatever list you come up with, I would be very surprised if anyone is already familiar with every last title. If you're aiming to publish the list by year's end, making the voting deadline 1 month before should be adequate time.kadian1365http://www.nihonreview.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5455108671364992297.post-6227784210966678802013-06-07T23:25:44.398-07:002013-06-07T23:25:44.398-07:00Some thoughts on the hall of fame idea (these are ...Some thoughts on the hall of fame idea (these are mainly influenced by the Wrestling Observer Hall of Fame).<br /><br />Limit it to anime made between 1963-2003. This will avoid a Hall of Fame being full of things that are simply freshest in people's minds. You could even make an argument for a fifteen year cut off.<br /><br />Some anime should be in a Hall of Fame without needing voting on. For example, an Anime Hall of Fame without Sazae-san is without credibility. My personal preference would be to just include everything that has aired continually for 10+ years without a vote (by my reckoning that's 9 shows).<br /><br />Limit each voter to 10 votes.<br /><br />Require 60% of the voters to vote for an anime before it gets in.<br /><br />Have nominations, rather than allowing people to choose from the whole of anime.<br /><br />Don't allow a public vote, limit the voter base to those who submitted to the blog.<br /><br />I would group franchises together as one vote. So you'd vote for Gundam or Lupin III, rather than voting for individual outings.Brian Smithhttp://awesome-engine.comnoreply@blogger.com